The Stoned Crab

The The Stoned Crab is located in Key West, Florida, right by the picturesque Ibis Bay Beach Resort and is known for its fresh seafood and delicious cocktails. This open, dockside location offers an inviting atmosphere and is the perfect place to enjoy the culinary delights of the region.

Ambiance and Atmosphere

The restaurant is characterized by its relaxed, airy atmosphere with a view of the calm waters, where shark feedings occasionally take place. Guests can dine while enjoying a refreshing breeze and the sound of the waves. The decor is modern and inviting, and the service is often described as friendly and accommodating. However, the nearby road can lead to some noise that may be bothersome for certain guests.

Food and Drinks

The menu at The Stoned Crab pays homage to local specialties, particularly the famous stone crabs. The restaurant sources its seafood daily from local fishermen who deliver freshly caught products by boat. Highlights include the renowned seafood buffet and creative cocktails made from organic and sustainable ingredients. While portion sizes are often generous, not all guests are satisfied with the taste and quality of the food. Reports of bland and overcooked dishes are increasing in reviews.

Prices and Reservations

Prices at The Stoned Crab are average, but one should expect to pay a bit more for fresh seafood. Substitutions of dishes or special requests sometimes seem to be unavailable, which can be disappointing for some guests. It is advisable to make reservations in advance, especially on weekends and during peak season, to secure a table.

Guest Experiences

Reviews

Guest opinions about The Stoned Crab vary greatly. Some praise the nice service and relaxed atmosphere, while others criticize the quality of the food. One guest mentioned that the seafood did not taste fresh and that they experienced health issues after the meal. Positive feedback has been given to the restaurant for the right ambiance and the opportunity to watch fishermen practice catch-and-release. Many guests appreciate the large selection of cocktails, although they complain about the high price for vacuum-sealed seafood. Overall, The Stoned Crab is often described as a place worth visiting once, but expectations should remain realistic.

Conclusion

The Stoned Crab is an interesting spot with much potential for an unforgettable meal in Key West. The combination of fresh seafood, a lovely atmosphere, and friendly service is certainly inviting. However, it is advisable to be aware of the mixed reviews and to consider food prices and previous critiques before a visit. For seafood and cocktail lovers wanting to experience the charm of Key West, it can still be an appealing stop.