Hungry Tarpon Restaurant

Introduction

The Hungry Tarpon Restaurant, located on the Overseas Highway in Islamorada, Florida, offers an inviting and casual atmosphere that perfectly fits the laid-back lifestyle of the Florida Keys. This fish restaurant is known for its fresh seafood and the opportunity to have your own catch prepared, making it a unique experience for both anglers and foodies alike.

Ambiance and Atmosphere

With a picturesque location by the water, the Hungry Tarpon Restaurant provides a beautiful view of the bay, especially impressive at sunset. The outdoor area, illuminated by tiki torches, creates a relaxed vacation vibe and offers the perfect backdrop for a romantic dinner or a casual gathering with friends. The atmosphere is lively and friendly, ideal for both locals and tourists.

Menu and Culinary Experiences

The menu at Hungry Tarpon features a variety of dishes prepared with fresh, local ingredients. Highlights include the famous Trailer Trash Bloody Marys, Conch Fritters, and the Blackened Mahi Reuben Sandwiches. Additionally, there’s the option to prepare your own catch, meaning anglers can enjoy their freshly caught fish in various preparations—ranging from grilling to frying to Thai-style cooking.

Prices and Versatility

The prices are mid-range, covering a wide selection. Breakfast dishes cost between $10 and $20, while lunch and dinner can range from $15 to $40 depending on the dish. The restaurant is particularly attractive for families, offering kid-friendly options and space for large groups.

Service and Customer Reviews

Guests frequently highlight the unusually good service, particularly praising the friendly and attentive service from staff members like Natalie. Many visitors seem enthusiastic about the top-notch quality of the food and the prompt service, even during peak hours. One person noted, "The food was quick and hot, even with a full restaurant." This demonstrates that the staff is well-trained to meet guest expectations even under high demand.

Tips for Your Visit

• Visit the restaurant early to secure a table with a view of the bay, especially during the peak season.
• Don’t forget to try the Trailer Trash Bloody Marys - they are a hit among guests!
• For anglers: Remember to bring your catches and try the Cook Your Catch option.

Reviews

The majority of reviews for the Hungry Tarpon Restaurant are overwhelmingly positive. Guests praise the quality of the food, especially the fresh seafood and cocktails. The service is often described as outstanding, with staff frequently presenting a smile and a warm approach. Many visitors consider the restaurant a must-stop on their journey through the Keys, with planned visits particularly during brunch. The restaurant is also pet-friendly, making it an ideal place for the entire travel group.