Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen

Visit Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen, a true paradise for sweet-tooths, in the heart of Key West! It is located on the picturesque Duval Street, the liveliest street on the island, and is known for its delicious treats, including giant cookies, homemade ice cream, and the famous Key Lime Pie. So if you smell sugar in the air, you know you've found the right place.

A Sweet Legacy

The tradition of Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen goes way back and reflects the company's passion for making high-quality candies. With two locations on the famous Duval Street, this candy kitchen focuses on using top-notch ingredients to create their heavenly cookies, creamy ice cream, and delicious stuffed fudge. It’s less about mass production and more about a love for the craft.

Facilities and Offerings

The main offering of the shop is the impressive cookies, which not only taste delicious but are as big as your face! The selection includes chocolate cookies, sugar cookies, and special editions like the peanut butter cookie topped with a delicious layer of fudge. Each cookie is freshly baked and can be warmed up slightly upon request – a little trick to enhance the flavor experience even more.

But that's not all! Mattheessen’s also offers an enticing range of homemade ice cream and milkshakes. Popular flavors like triple chocolate ice cream and birthday cake will make your taste buds dance. If you haven't tried it yet, you definitely need to sample the Key Lime Pie, a true classic that is a must-have in this region.

Costs and Tips

Prices here can sometimes come as a little surprise. Many guests report a total of about $30 for three large cookies. A higher price may apply for the special fudge cookies, but the investment is well worth it when you take a bite into the sweet delights. Remember that you also have the option to take various samples before making a flavor decision.

Location and Contact

The address of the first location is 419 D Duval Street, Key West, FL 33040, USA, and you can reach the team at (305) 923-5418. It is advisable to visit their website for the latest information on opening hours and offerings.

Reviews

Visitor feedback for Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen is overwhelmingly positive. Many describe the atmosphere as inviting and the selection of treats as overwhelming. The cookies are often highlighted as the main focus, with their size and delicious taste being praised repeatedly. Guests appreciate the opportunity to sample the fantastic ice cream before making a final choice. Overall, Mattheessen’s is regarded as an excellent spot for a sweet snack or dessert in Key West.